How we choose the right birth control pill to start—and how we decide whether it’s the right one to continue—can be more complex than it seems. While most people initially think of the pill as a contraceptive, it’s actually a powerful tool for managing a variety of reproductive and general health issues.
It’s important to understand that birth control selection should be an ongoing dialogue between you and your provider, not a one-time decision. Your needs may evolve, and so might your body’s response to different formulations. Let’s break down what goes into the process of choosing the right pill for you.
1. Contraceptive Effectiveness
Oral contraceptives are highly effective when taken consistently. Most birth control pills suppress ovulation reliably, and failure rates are low—typically 2 to 3 pregnancies per 100 women per year. While older studies showed even lower rates, recent real-world data reflect slightly higher pregnancy rates, possibly due to changes in adherence or population factors like obesity. A few medications can alter effectiveness as well.
Key point: All combination pills are similarly effective when taken as directed. So, when we choose a pill, we’re not choosing it for effectiveness—we’re choosing it for how well it fits your health profile and goals.
2. Safety First
Since the 1970s, changes in pill formulations have prioritized safety, with lower doses and refined hormone types. Today’s pills are remarkably safe for most users. Not much testing is really needed, your provider will recommend if you need pap smears, mammograms, or blood testing before getting a pill prescription.
However, selecting the safest pill for you requires a detailed medical history. Factors like:
-
High blood pressure
-
Diabetes
-
Migraines (especially with aura)
-
Blood clotting disorders
-
Obesity: Higher BMI can slightly increase the risk of blood clots with estrogen-containing pills. This doesn’t automatically disqualify you, but it’s something your provider will consider when selecting the safest option.
Lower estrogen doses are safer overall, but sometimes a slightly higher dose may be recommended in specific cases (e.g., for bone health in teens or better menstrual control).
3. Health Benefits Beyond Birth Control
This is where individualization really shines. Many women benefit from birth control pills for reasons unrelated to contraception, such as:
-
Cycle control and reduction of menstrual cramps
-
Management of PCOS symptoms: acne, hair growth, irregular cycles
-
Reduction in risk of ovarian cysts, endometriosis, and certain gynecologic cancers such as uterine and ovarian cancer
-
Treatment of PMS, PMDD, heavy bleeding, and hormonal acne
-
Even hair loss or hirsutism can improve with the right formulation
However, it needs to be the right pill. For example, progestin-only pills (or “mini pills”) don’t offer the same benefits for acne or hirsutism as combined estrogen-progestin pills.
4. Fertility Preservation & STI Risk Reduction
While the pill doesn’t protect against STIs, it can reduce the risk of tubal infections (salpingitis), which in turn helps preserve fertility. You may also experience fewer fibroids and lighter, more manageable periods. Pills also allow you to have a pregnancy planning visit to make sure health risks are addressed before pregnancy.
If you’re thinking about pregnancy in the near future, don’t stop your pill abruptly on your own. It’s a good idea to talk to your provider before coming off the pill. This allows us to plan your transition thoughtfully, discuss timing, and assess any fertility or cycle-related concerns you might have.
5. Side Effects and Real-World Use
Side effects can be a major reason why people stop taking the pill, which can leave them unprotected. Common issues like nausea, mood changes, or breakthrough bleeding can often be managed—sometimes by switching to another pill.
This is why follow-up matters. If you’re having side effects or not feeling confident in your method, don’t tough it out—schedule a check-in. Many times, small adjustments can make a big difference.
6. Special Considerations: Teens and Bone Health
In very young users, especially those still building peak bone mass, the lowest dose pills may not always be ideal. In some cases, a slightly higher estrogen dose is better for long-term skeletal health. Again, this is a nuanced conversation worth having with your provider.
The Bottom Line: It’s a Journey, Not a One-Time Choice
Choosing the right birth control is not static. What works well for you at age 19 might not be ideal at 29—or 39. This is why it’s essential to keep an open, ongoing dialogue with your provider. Talk about your symptoms, side effects, goals, and even concerns about long-term risks or fertility.
When you come in for your visit, we’ll go over what’s working, what’s not, and adjust as needed. And remember: Your preferences and comfort always matter.
📞 Call to schedule a consult or follow-up today:
217-356-3736
Let’s make sure your birth control is working for you—not against you.
Let me know if you’d like this version formatted for your website, turned into a downloadable handout, or adapted for social media!
